How should you rent out surplus space at your premises?

An increase in homeworking by your staff means you have surplus space in your office that could be rented out. Should you rent out a room or clearly defined area to tenants or let them use unoccupied rooms on an ad hoc basis?

How should you rent out surplus space at your premises?

Different VAT outcomes

If you rent out a specified area of land to your tenants, such as a room or entire floor in your building, you are making a land supply, which will be exempt from VAT in most cases. The exception is if you have opted to tax your building with HMRC, when the income will be subject to VAT.

However, if you let them occupy an ad hoc part of your building that is available on a particular day, such as an empty chair and desk, you are making a charge for “use of facilities” or granting a “right to trade” which is standard-rated.

Example. The owner of a hairdressing salon allows a self-employed beauty consultant to trade on the premises. The consultant is not given her own room, using whatever chairs and tables are available when she arrives. The payments she makes to the salon owner will be standard-rated.

To qualify as a land supply, HMRC’s guidance and the legislation are clear that your tenant must have sole use of a room or particular part of the building, to the exclusion of all other persons.

You should draft a simple agreement with potential building users, making it clear what facilities you are supplying and for how long.

Why is the difference important?

If your prospective tenants are able to fully claim input tax, it will make no difference if your fees are exempt or standard-rated, i.e. VAT is not a cost to their business. However, many tenants will not be able to claim VAT because:

  • they trade below the compulsory registration threshold, so are not registered
  • their supplies are partly or wholly exempt from VAT, so they cannot claim input tax because of partial exemption, e.g. a financial advisor; or
  • they might be a charity or not-for-profit organisation with non-business activities.

There is no problem with a mix and match outcome, i.e. you could rent out rooms and specified areas to some tenants but ad hoc facilities to others.

Supply of other benefits

HMRC will sometimes argue that rent-a-room arrangements are still subject to VAT because your business might provide other services and benefits to the tenants. An example they have pursued is that hairdressing salons providing towels, reception services and cleaning arrangements to their tenants are making a supply of “more than land”.

You must consider if these services are incidental to the type of arrangement you are supplying or whether they are worthwhile extra benefits that affect the VAT position. Factors to review include the basis of pricing; the costs and time your business incurs in supplying the extra benefits; the motive for providing these extra services, e.g. are you generating extra income or just ensuring you have a happy tenant.

HMRC has lost several tribunal cases on the extra benefits issue. If challenged by an officer, you can quote the case of Errol Willy Salons Ltd [2022] . In this case, the judge ruled that the predominant supply was the passive letting of bare rooms to tenants, i.e. exempt from VAT.